Write an essay which displays evidence of analytical and critical skills in the area of Management Development. Choose from ONE of the following questions:
• ‘The soft skills in management are the most vital but they are also the most un-teachable. If you don’t have self- insight and can’t develop yourself, you won’t go far’. Argue analytically for or against this proposition using evidence.
• ‘Using the classroom to help develop people already practising management is a fine idea, but pretending to create managers out of people who have never managed is a sham’. Critically debate this proposition drawing on the literature on management education and, if possible, your own experience.
• With reference to the literature, critically consider the themes and trends in MD/LD and critically assess with evidence and reasoned argument how they may evolve in the future.
• Do you think leadership development and management development will continue to co-exist or will one dimension supplant the other? Debate this analytically with balanced use of evidence.
• ‘Formal and informal development need each other. Neither is complete without the other. The trick is to draw out the strengths of both for any group of learners’. Investigate this statement critically.
• ‘Leadership development is a matter for top management’. Critically evaluate this ambiguous statement.
• Leadership development is just the re-branding of management development: ‘old wine in new bottles’. Argue critically for or against this claim.
• Henry Mintzberg, the management guru, has written a major work attacking MBAs as a way of developing managers. He says that they ‘train the wrong people in the wrong ways with the wrong consequences’. Interpret and argue with evidence.
• ‘Succession management and career management are dying as the structure of work, management and organisations change’ Critically discuss.
• ‘Evaluating the effectiveness of a MD/LD programme in the real world is just too difficult. Best not to try’. Critically appraise this claim.
In April 1992, when a for the most part white jury cleared four cops blamed in the recorded beating for a dark driver, a large number of individuals in Los Angeles, predominantly youthful dark and Latino guys, participated in what has regularly been described as a race revolt. In the mid year of 2001, ethnic mobs happened in the city of towns and urban communities in the north of England (Oldham, Leeds, Burnley, Bradford), including youthful British Asian men and youthful White British men. All the more as of late, in November 2005, riots rose in Paris’ rural areas, started by the coincidental passings of two Muslim young people, and after that spread to 300 French towns and urban communities. The greater part of the agitators were the French-conceived offspring of foreigners from Arab and African nations, an expansive rate being Muslim. These race and ethnic mobs have all as of late set the issue of racial and ethnic character at the front line of political civil argument in the United States and in Europe. In this paper, we attempt to examine numerous issues particularly on sex issues, relationship issues, family issues, idea of excellence, ladies in games and relocation issues. The way the characters carried on and how alternate characters acted towards them depicts the topic and the issues included. Sex issue is depicted through Indian convictions and in addition Western convictions. The conventional idea that young ladies ought not be associated with sports existed in both the Indian family and in addition the England family. This can be seen in both Jesminder’s family and also Catherine’s family where their mom’s unequivocally demoralized them from playing soccer as soccer is implied just for the young men. The two moms can’t endure the possibility that their little girls are playing and getting a charge out of soccer in this way a wide range of comedies followed in light of the varying thoughts moms and girls have. Through sex issues, the conventional idea of excellence is additionally delineated. Anything that is appalling must be covered up while things that are not of social standards are disapproved of. For instance, in the Indian family, Jesminder’s mom was stunned that her little girl would uncover her scars just to wear shorts to play soccer. Indian young ladies should conceal their bodies and should not spruce up like the young men. Jesminder’s mom additionally does not need Jesminder to play soccer since it makes her end up dim and along these lines she isn’t lovely. This discernments make Jesminder put on a façade. Before her relatives, she spruced up like an obedient Indian girl. Behind them, she strips to her pullover and shorts with a specific end goal to seek after her enthusiasm. Diversion is made through such discernments and the things done by Jesminder to ‘twist’ the principles but then have all the earmarks of being an obedient little girl in her parent’s eyes. With respect to the England family, Catherine’s mom needs her little girl to be cultured. It is very clever when mother and little girl went shopping and the mother demands that her girl wears a push-up bra. This run of the mill thought on how young ladies should doll up is profoundly entertaining as the mother is upholding her little girl something that she isn’t. This demonstrates the custom thought of excellence exist among the Indians as well as the England individuals also. Issues on gays and lesbianism have likewise been addressed in this motion picture. Gays and lesbianism isn’t acknowledged in the two social orders. For instance, Jesminder’s male closest companion admits to her that he enjoys David Beckham. The issue on him being gay is kept quieted among them as being Indians; they shouldn’t conflict with social and customary standards by getting to be gay. Lesbianism is touched upon when Catherine’s mom accepted that Catherine and Jesminder are lesbian couples. Because of her eruptions, diversion was made. This demonstrates Indians still adhere to their conventional culture while England individuals are not that best in class in their reasoning either. The customary issue on marriage still exists among the Indian characters in this motion picture. Pinky’s beau bankrupt up their engagement in light of the fact that Jesminder, Pinky’s sister, was seen embracing an England kid. This demonstrates the injustice that comes to pass for on Pinky for something she has not done. To increase the comic impact, the ‘kid’ Jesminder was embracing is really a young lady. Catherine was mixed up to be a kid since she has short hair. By and by, the customary idea of magnificence on how young ladies’ hair length ought to be sneaks in. Jesminder additionally declines to illuminate her family that her England mentor is her beau for expecting that her folks couldn’t acknowledge the thought. Along these lines this demonstrates they are as yet conventional. Aside from sexual orientation issues, family issues and relationship issues, movement issues likewise assume a huge part in this film. Their home is an image to demonstrate how the Indian family has acclimatized to the England society. The semi-separated house is an impression of how the family has mixed into England while in the meantime safeguarding their social roots and foundation. The intermittent lights showed on the house demonstrate the distinction of the family contrasted with whatever is left of the area. Notwithstanding, this distinction has likewise been acknowledged by the general public there as the lights gave out a lovely impact. This film additionally looks at ladies who must disclose their decision to take part in a game, which generally men just contended in. It was noticed that how a lady who plays soccer and delighted in it colossally and even longed for playing professionally, needed to beat the customary thoughts of her family with a specific end goal to accomplish what she needed the most. It introduces a horde of complex issues and shows them in a way that is engaging and empowering. In this film, ladies in wear is an issue, however one that has come far in the historical backdrop of ladies and game now, in any event in soccer, ladies can and do play professionally and that isn’t an odd or amazing thing. Ladies are currently ready to play sports; in any case, there are still snags and generalizations which the characters still come into contact with and manage regularly. Jules, one of the fundamental characters, needs to live with her mom who tries so difficult to make her more female; while Jess, the primary character, should live with the customary ideas and encounters of her family. One might say that “Twist It Like Beckham” truly displayed a more practical case of the impediments that ladies confront, by taking a gander at one individual and her particular conditions. It takes into account a circumstance in which Jess must battle for what she has faith in and endeavor to propel her own family. This film likewise got inquiries of gentility as well as sex issues and sexual orientation relations, and being a lady playing sports today. There are still generalizations and goals about ladies that are not really written in stone any more, and it creates the impression that we can anticipate a future where those generalizations may never again be so profoundly imbedded. The families learnt to acclimatize into England’s way of life through their youngsters’ involvement. Pinky’s capacity to locate an Indian spouse and proceeding onward with her life makes fulfillment among her relatives. This demonstrates they have a place in the general public. Jesminder’s accomplishments in her A Levels examinations and her capacity to qualify in an England soccer group for young ladies likewise demonstrate that absorption and acknowledgment has occurred. The comic impact that was delivered in this motion picture mirrors the things that happen in the general public and shows how the general public adjusts to it. The Indian family figured out how to safeguard their conventional and social roots in spite of being far from India. Westerners are additionally not saved from conventional reasoning. We infer that extreme types of ethnic character and socialization have all the earmarks of being framed in social settings in which the minority ethnic attribute is generally “debilitated” either straightforwardly by the activities of the lion’s share gathering or in a roundabout way just by being presented to the connection with the larger part standard of conduct in a blended neighborhood. Twist It Like Beckham’ is about a young lady’s look for social personality in the 21st Century England.>