Please watch the following video and the answer the following prompt:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vUwpZ7mLIVA
Dr. J. Marion Sims became known as the "Father of American Gynecology." She also notes that by "examining the work of enslaved women patients and nurses through the prism of nineteenth-century racial formation theory, we can better understand not only the science of race but also the contradictions inherent in slavery and medicine that allowed an allegedly inferior racial group to perform professional labor requiring substantial intellectual ability" (p. 2). Cooper-Owens argues for the designation of 10 enslaved Black women patients and nurses as the "mothers" of American Gynecology. Do you think her argument is valid? Provide rationale from the text to support your response.
No More Worries!
Paper Formatting
- Double or single-spaced
- 1-inch margin
- 12 Font Arial or Times New Roman
- 300 words per page
No Lateness!
Our orders are delivered strictly on time without delay
AEW Guarantees
- Free Unlimited revisions
- Guaranteed Privacy
- Money Return guarantee
- Plagiarism Free Writing
A video analysis
Full Answer Section
In particular, Dr. Cooper-Owens highlights the contributions of the following 10 enslaved Black women:
- Anarcha Westcott
- Betsey
- Celia
- Lucy
- Mahala
- Marion Sims' wife, Nancy
- Phyllis
- Rosa
- Sally
- Susan
- Tildy
These women were all subjected to invasive and often painful experiments by Dr. Sims, but they also provided him with valuable insights into female anatomy and physiology. They also served as nurses and midwives, providing care to other enslaved women and their children.
Dr. Cooper-Owens argues that these women deserve to be recognized as the "mothers" of American Gynecology because of their significant contributions to the field. She also argues that their designation as such would help to correct the historical erasure of Black women's contributions to medicine and science.
I agree with Dr. Cooper-Owens that these women deserve to be recognized for their contributions to gynecology. Their stories are a reminder of the important role that Black women have played in the development of medicine, and of the need to continue to fight for racial justice in the healthcare system.
It is also important to note that Dr. Cooper-Owens' argument is not without its critics. Some historians argue that it is unfair to designate these women as the "mothers" of gynecology because they were not able to fully consent to the experiments that were performed on them. Others argue that it is important to recognize the contributions of all those who have contributed to the field of gynecology, regardless of their race or gender.
Despite these criticisms, I believe that Dr. Cooper-Owens' argument is valid and important. Her work helps to shed light on the hidden history of Black women's contributions to medicine, and it challenges us to rethink the traditional narratives of medical progress.
Sample Answer
Yes, I believe Dr. Cooper-Owens' argument that 10 enslaved Black women patients and nurses should be designated as the "mothers" of American Gynecology is valid. She provides convincing evidence in her text to support her claim, including:
- The fact that Dr. J. Marion Sims, the "Father of American Gynecology," conducted many of his experiments on enslaved Black women without their consent.
- The fact that enslaved Black women played a vital role in the development of gynecology, both as patients and nurses.
- The fact that enslaved Black women's contributions to gynecology have been largely ignored and erased from history.
12% Discount
- Research Paper Writing
- Essay Writing
- Dissertation Writing
- Thesis Writing
Why Choose Us
- Money Return guarantee
- Guaranteed Privacy
- Written by Professionals
- Paper Written from Scratch
- Timely Deliveries
- Free Amendments