Scenario 1:
What should Dr. Smith do? Give three reasons why Dr. Smith should not clone Lucy, and three reasons why she should.
If Mr. Luning offers her not only money, but future funding for her research, should this make a difference in Dr. Smith's decision? Why or why not?
Dr. Smith would be the first to clone a human, and she could have the most modern laboratory with everything that she could possibly need. Should
this play a part in her decision? Defend your answer.
Should scientists do everything that they are technologically capable of doing? Give four arguments to support your answer.
Will there be a market for human cloning? Why or why not?
Scenario 2:
What should Coach Smith do? List three things.
Should the College be told if the coach decides to suggest the hormone to his players? Why or why not?
The HGH has to be administered by injection. Who should perform the injections? Why?
If a player doesn't want to take the HGH, what should Coach Smith do? Why?
Coach Smith has already approached a drug company manufacturing HGH. The company will donate the drug and test the players for side effects.
Should the coach agree to this? Why or why not?
What are the legal ramifications of using HGH on his players?
What are the medical ramifications of using HGH on the players?
Sample Solution