Watch Star Trek: The Next Generation The Measure of a Man". (We will watch it in class).
If you have not seen the episode, you may refer to the STAR TREK SUMMARY and the Videos and summary of the in Modules/ Schedule and Readings.
Instructions:
- Briefly explain what the Star Trek episode is about. What is the main issue discussed in the episode? Describe the philosophical issues involved in the episode. Only explain the relevant aspects of the plot. (Do not copy and paste from the internet, or the summary below). 2. Briefly explain Nagel's theory of Consciousness. Be sure to cite page numbers. 3. Give me an argument for why Data is, or is not conscious. 4. Give an argument for why Data is, or is not a person. Who is "Data"?—what do you think is the identity of Data? Is Data a "person"? Why or why not. 5. At the end, the JAG officer made a ruling giving Data the right to choose. Is the ruling right granting Data his right to refuse? Discuss the issues for granting Data his right to refuse, or can he be forced to undergo the procedure? Why? Explain your argument sufficiently, using details, analogies, or other examples. Always include citation and bibliography.
Sample Solution