Compare and contrast two evidence based models that work effectively with substance abuse in the criminal justice system. Include how this model best fits in your agency, focusing on the likelihood/feasibility of adoption in your organization. Be sure to focus on economic, human resource, therapist expertise, and other relevant factors. Evidence-based approaches to drug addiction treatment are discussed in the “Principles of Drug Addiction Treatment”
Evidence based models that work effectively with substance abuse in the criminal justice system.
Sample Answer
Comparing Evidence-Based Models for Substance Abuse in the Criminal Justice System
Two prominent evidence-based models that effectively address substance abuse in the criminal justice system are Drug Courts and Therapeutic Communities (TCs). While both aim to reduce substance use and criminal behavior, they differ significantly in their structure, approach, and resource demands.1. Drug Courts
Description: Drug Courts are specialized court dockets that integrate substance abuse treatment with justice system case processing. They involve a collaborative, non-adversarial approach, bringing together judges, prosecutors, defense attorneys, treatment providers, probation officers, and case managers. Participants undergo intensive treatment, regular drug testing, judicial supervision, incentives for compliance, and sanctions for non-compliance, all while being held accountable by the court. The goal is to divert non-violent, drug-involved offenders from traditional incarceration into a closely monitored treatment program.Full Answer Section
Key Features:- Judicial Oversight: Active and regular involvement of a dedicated judge.
- Integrated Services: Coordination of treatment, legal, and social services.
- Frequent Testing: Regular and random drug testing to monitor sobriety.
- Incentives and Sanctions: A system of rewards for progress and immediate, predictable consequences for infractions.
- Team Approach: Collaboration among justice and treatment professionals.
2. Therapeutic Communities (TCs)
Description: Therapeutic Communities are highly structured residential or non-residential treatment programs where the "community" itself is the primary therapeutic agent. TCs typically involve a hierarchical structure, peer-driven activities, confrontation and support groups, and a focus on social learning and personal responsibility. Residents take on increasing levels of responsibility within the community as they progress through treatment phases, learning new coping skills, addressing criminal thinking patterns, and developing prosocial behaviors. Key Features:- Community as Method: The peer community, supported by staff, facilitates change through mutual self-help.
- Structured Environment: Highly organized daily routines, work assignments, and group activities.
- Hierarchical Structure: Residents progress through stages, gaining privileges and responsibilities.
- Confrontation and Support: Open and honest feedback, balanced with strong peer and staff support.
- Focus on Behavior and Values: Emphasizes personal accountability, moral integrity, and social responsibility.