Freud, Jung & the Unconscious

  1. I characterized Freud’s and Jung’s work as “first person psychology,” as opposed to prevailing “third person” approaches. Is this a viable project? Can introspection be rigorous? What are the strengths and weaknesses of this approach vis-à-vis what have become standard paradigms?
  2. How does Freud interpret “the dream of the botanical monograph”? Is his interpretation persuasive? Why or why not?
  3. How is the unconscious like a dissident artist, and what might that tell us about the unconscious and about art?
  4. Is the depth psychology we have studied in texts by Freud and Jung a science? An art? What is it exactly?
  5. Discuss Jung’s concept of synchronicity as displayed in The Red Book.
  6. What kind of a text is The Red Book? Does it belong within any recognizable tradition? If so, who are its ancestors?
  7. What were the most important differences between Freud and Jung? Freud never saw The Red Book. What would have been his response?
  8. Is The Red Book a classic or a curiosity? Should it be read in Great Books courses? In Psychology courses? Why?
  9. Discuss Jungian psychology in light of cultural anthropology. To what extent does Jung seek to recapitulate earlier forms of consciousness? To what extent is his Red Book a general critique of modernity?

Sample Solution