Share an ethical argument based on a real-world experience you have encountered. Be sure to share a different experience than the one you chose for the Module One journal reflection. What claim does the argument make? How is this claim supported by evidence?
- Share an example of an ethical conflict in a specific workplace. Your example can be one that you witnessed or heard about. Or you may choose a true or fictional example from a book, a television show, or a movie.
- Discuss a framework or principle that is being challenged in the example.
What solution would you recommend that would satisfy the principle? Be sure to support your proposed solution with reasoning.
Full Answer Section
Ethical Framework Challenged:
This scenario challenges the ethical principle of patient autonomy. Patient autonomy is the right of individuals to make informed decisions about their own healthcare. By overriding the patient's wishes, the healthcare provider undermined this fundamental principle.
Recommended Solution:
To rectify this ethical dilemma, the healthcare provider should have engaged in a respectful and empathetic dialogue with the patient. The provider should have fully explained the risks and benefits of both options, allowing the patient to make an informed decision without feeling pressured or coerced. If the patient's decision differed from the provider's recommendation, the provider should have respected the patient's autonomy and provided the necessary support.
By prioritizing patient autonomy and informed consent, healthcare providers can build trust with their patients, improve patient satisfaction, and ultimately enhance the quality of care.
Ethical Conflict in the Workplace
Consider a scenario where a marketing team is tasked with creating an advertising campaign for a new product. The team is under pressure to meet a tight deadline and exceed sales targets. In an effort to achieve these goals, they decide to use misleading advertising tactics, such as exaggerating the product's benefits or downplaying its limitations.
Ethical Framework Challenged:
This scenario challenges the ethical principle of honesty and transparency. By using deceptive advertising practices, the marketing team is misleading consumers and undermining trust.
Recommended Solution:
To address this ethical conflict, the marketing team should prioritize honesty and transparency in their advertising. They should accurately represent the product's features, benefits, and limitations. By adhering to ethical guidelines and industry standards, the team can build trust with consumers and avoid potential legal and reputational risks.
Additionally, the company should establish a strong ethical code of conduct and provide regular ethics training to employees. This can h
Sample Answer
Ethical Argument: A Real-World Experience
Ethical Argument:
The ethical argument I'd like to present stems from a real-world experience involving a healthcare setting. The claim is that prioritizing patient autonomy and informed consent is essential, even when it conflicts with medical paternalism.
Evidence:
I once witnessed a situation where a healthcare provider, despite possessing superior medical knowledge, disregarded a patient's explicit wishes regarding a particular treatment plan. The patient, fully informed of the risks and benefits, made a decision that differed from the provider's recommendation. However, the provider, believing their judgment to be superior, insisted on a different course of action.