Spotlight on Youth Organizing
1) In what ways are youth marginalized or vulnerable community members? In what ways do they have power and privilege?
2) Discuss how intersectionality affects youth organizers. Consider the realities of race and ethnicity, gender, class, and sexual orientation.
3) What techniques can be used to strengthen the collective efficacy of a group of youth who share some similarities and common goals but have significant diversities among them (e.g., related to class, immigration status, gender identity, or race or ethnicity)?
4) Sometimes community organizing is risky business as youth speak truth to power and take direct action. What are the ethical responsibilities that practitioners have to youth in terms of: a. ensuring their basic needs are met (emotional, physical, etc.); b. avoiding unintended consequences that speaking out or engaging in direct action may have for them; c. attending to the realities of youth who are particularly vulnerable (e.g., immigrant youth).
5) How do we attend to these issues while still embracing the value of self-determination (i.e., that they have rights to make choices for their lives)?
Sample Answer
Analyzing Youth Vulnerability, Privilege, and Organizing
1) In what ways are youth marginalized or vulnerable community members? In what ways do they have power and privilege?
Youth, generally defined as individuals between childhood and adulthood, occupy a complex social position characterized by both marginalization and potential privilege.
Marginalization and Vulnerability:
- Dependence and Lack of Autonomy: Youth are often legally and economically dependent on adults (parents, guardians, caregivers). This can limit their autonomy in decision-making regarding their education, healthcare, living situations, and overall well-being. They may have limited control over their finances and resources.
- Limited Legal Rights and Protections: While laws exist to protect youth, they often have fewer legal rights than adults. For example, they may have restrictions on their ability to enter into contracts, vote, consume alcohol or tobacco, or make independent medical decisions. This can make them vulnerable to exploitation and limit their ability to advocate for themselves.
- Social and Cultural Disempowerment: Youth voices and perspectives are often undervalued or dismissed in adult-dominated spaces. They may lack the social capital and influence of adults, making it harder to be taken seriously in community and political discussions. This can lead to feelings of frustration and disengagement.