The key differences between probation and parole supervision

Discuss the key differences between probation and parole supervision, including how offenders are placed on these types of supervision. As part of your response evaluate the three (3) styles (law enforcement, counselor, and social worker) of community corrections supervision that an officer might adapt with respect to how they might be used on different types of offenders to increase the chances of rehabilitation success.

find the cost of your paper

Sample Answer

 

 

 

 

 

Community corrections play a vital role in the criminal justice system by supervising offenders outside of secure correctional facilities. Two primary forms of community supervision are probation and parole, which, while similar in their goal of reintegration and public safety, differ significantly in their application and how offenders are placed on them.

 

Key Differences Between Probation and Parole Supervision

 

Probation:

  • Placement: Probation is a court-ordered sentence imposed in lieu of or in conjunction with incarceration. A judge decides to place an offender on probation as part of their initial sentencing, typically after a conviction for a crime. It is often seen as an alternative to prison or jail time, particularly for less serious offenses or for first-time offenders.
  • Timing: It occurs before or instead of a period of incarceration.
  • Authority: The authority to grant and oversee probation rests primarily with the courts.
  • Purpose: The primary purpose is rehabilitation and accountability, allowing offenders to remain in the community, maintain employment, and support their families while still being supervised and adhering to court-imposed conditions.

Full Answer Section

 

 

 

 

 

Parole:

  • Placement: Parole is a period of conditional supervised release granted after an offender has served a portion of their prison sentence. The decision to grant parole is typically made by a parole board (or similar administrative body), which reviews an inmate’s suitability for release based on factors like their behavior in prison, rehabilitation efforts, and risk to the community.
  • Timing: It occurs after a period of incarceration.
  • Authority: The authority to grant and oversee parole rests primarily with a parole board or state correctional agencies.
  • Purpose: The primary purpose is to facilitate the structured reintegration of individuals back into the community after imprisonment, while still ensuring public safety through continued supervision and adherence to release conditions.

Commonalities: Both probation and parole involve a set of conditions that offenders must abide by (e.g., regular reporting to an officer, maintaining employment, abstaining from drugs/alcohol, avoiding criminal activity), and violations can lead to revocation and potential incarceration. Both are supervised by community corrections officers (often referred to as probation or parole officers).

 

Styles of Community Corrections Supervision and Their Application for Rehabilitation Success

 

Community corrections officers often adapt different supervision styles based on the needs and risks of the offenders on their caseloads. These styles can be broadly categorized as:

  1. Law Enforcement (Control/Surveillance) Style:
    • Description: This style emphasizes strict enforcement of conditions, surveillance, and deterrence. The officer acts more like a police officer, focusing on detecting violations, conducting searches, and ensuring compliance through monitoring. There’s a strong emphasis on public safety and immediate sanctions for non-compliance.
    • Application for Rehabilitation Success:
      • High-Risk Offenders: This style is often appropriate for offenders with a history of serious offenses, high risk of recidivism, or those who pose a significant threat to public safety (e.g., violent offenders, repeat offenders, individuals with extensive criminal records). The strict monitoring and immediate consequences can deter further criminal behavior and provide a necessary level of control.
      • Unmotivated or Resistant Offenders: For individuals who are initially unmotivated or resistant to rehabilitation efforts, a strong law enforcement presence might be necessary to establish boundaries and enforce compliance before more rehabilitative approaches can be introduced.
      • Initial Stages of Supervision: Even for offenders who might eventually benefit from other styles, a more stringent law enforcement approach might be adopted at the beginning of supervision to establish authority and ensure initial compliance.
      • Caution: Over-reliance on this style without addressing underlying needs can be counterproductive for rehabilitation, as it may foster resentment and resistance, potentially leading to a cycle of violations and re-incarceration.
  2. Counselor (Rehabilitative/Treatment) Style:
    • Description: This style emphasizes guidance, support, and facilitating access to treatment and rehabilitative services. The officer acts as a mentor or case manager, helping offenders identify and address criminogenic needs (e.g., substance abuse, anger management, lack of education/employment skills, cognitive distortions). The focus is on behavioral change and skill-building.

This question has been answered.

Get Answer