Briefly introduce the problem area that the article seeks to address. Next, introduce the article (using a proper intext citation). Briefly summarize the study’s methodology and the main goals of the study.
Article Evaluation
Provide a brief overview of the components of the article that you will evaluate.
Measurement
Paragraph 1: Briefly describe the measurement strategy the authors used. What are the strengths and weaknesses
of this approach? (You may have to consult an outside resource to fully address this question.)
Paragraph 2: How else might these variables have been measured? What would have been the relative
advantages or disadvantages of this alternate approach?
Sampling
Paragraph 1: Briefly describe the sample. Is there any important information missing from the sample
description? How might this missing information affect the results of the study?
Paragraph 2: To whom are the authors seeking to generalize? What limitations related to the sample do the
authors mention? Can you think of any flaws related to sampling that the authors fail to mention that may limit
the generalizability of the sample?
Analysis
Paragraph 1: Explain and critique the authors’ assumptions about the causal order of the independent and
dependent variables?
Paragraph 2: Do the authors acknowledge or discuss the possibility that the direction of causality be reversed?
Provide one specific, plausible example of how the direction of causality may have been reversed.
Ethics
Paragraph 1: Summarize the authors’ discussion of the study’s ethical considerations. What safeguards were put
in place to protect the rights and safety of the participants?
9/27/2020 Writers Hub - Freelance Writing
https://www.writershub.org/writer/orders/642137#instructions 5/6
Paragraph 2: What potentially important issues were mentioned only briefly or not at all? Provide a specific
example of a potential ethical issue that was not discussed in the article and suggest a way in which the
researchers could have addressed it.
Conclusion
Based on the above criteria, provide your overall impression of the quality of the article. What suggestions
would you offer to future researchers interested in exploring this topic?
Sample Solution