Various defenses in contract formation
Discuss the various defenses in contract formation, stating what is required to establish each individual defense, and providing examples of when the defense may be found valid.
Sly Salesperson sells cars. While selling a car, Sly Salesperson tells the potential buyer that “this is the best car around. It’s a great car and sips gas.” The car has an average fuel rating. Has Sly Salesperson committed a misrepresentation? Fraud? Why or why not? Does the analysis change if Sly Salesperson says the car get 40 miles per gallon, but in fact the car only gets 30 miles per gallon?
Sample Answer
Defenses in Contract Formation
These defenses, if proven, can render a contract void or voidable, meaning it’s either unenforceable or can be canceled by the injured party.
- Lack of Capacity:
- Requirements: A party lacks the legal capacity to enter a contract. This usually applies to minors, those with mental incapacities, or intoxicated individuals.
- Examples:
- A 16-year-old enters a contract to buy a car. The contract is voidable by the minor.
- An individual with severe dementia signs a contract during a period of mental incapacity.